Sodium-hypochlorite vs. EOXIDE LQ 85
Chlorine is the most common chemical disinfectant but the question is: Is disinfection with chlorine really safe and reliable?
Sodium-hypochlorite |
eOxide® LQ 85 solution |
Sodium hypochlorite used for water disinfection (professional use) contains between 10% -15% active ingredient. |
eOxide LQ 85 is a 99% pure chlorine dioxide in a 0,75% solution which contains no free chlorine and chlorite when dosed into the water. |
Sodium hypochlorite generates hazardous byproducts like THM’s , HAA’s and Mutagen X in contact with organic material in the water. These by products are very strongly linked to cancer. |
eOxide LQ 85 will not generate hazardous byproducts in contact with organic material in the water. Rest products of eOxide LQ 85 0.75% are sodium sulfate and sodium chloride. These levels are NEGLIGIBLE. |
Sodium hypochlorite can be dosed in the water by using standard dosing pumps. Residual levels can be measured by membrane sensors and/or photometer. |
eOxide LQ 85 can be dosed in the water by using standard dosing pumps. Residual levels can be measured by membrane sensors and/or photometer. |
Sodium hypochlorite is strongly pH dependant and is efficient by pH 7 to 7,5. pH level of the water has to be balanced and corrected for disinfection reasons. |
eOxide LQ 85 works 100% effective between pH 4 and pH 10 and does not have to be corrected or balanced for disinfection reasons. |
Sodium hypochlorite is very corrosive for all kinds of materials, pipes and dosing equipment. |
eOxide LQ 85 0.75% solution is NOT corrosive when dosed into the water only when the pH of the water is <4. |
Sodium hypochlorite is not selective and reacts with all kind of organic materials present in the water and is consumed very fast for this reason. |
eOxide LQ 85 is highly selective and for this reason it will remain active for a long time in the distribution network. This implies that a long residual function of eOxide LQ 85 can be achieved (up-to 72 hours) in water distribution systems. This is LONGER than sodium hypochlorite. |
Sodium hypochlorite is not effective in removing a bio-film and preventing the growth of a bio-film in storage tanks and/or distribution systems. A shock dose with sodium hypochlorite can damage the material of the tank/pipes because it is highly corrosive. |
eOxide LQ 85 is highly effective in removing a bio-film and preventing the growth of a bio-film in storage tanks and/or distribution systems. A present bio-film can be removed by a shock dose of 30 mg/l and a contact time of 8 hours. A low continuous dosage (0,05 to 0,2 mg/l) will prevent the re-growth of the bio film. A shock dose will not damage the material of the tank/pipes because the product is not corrosive when dosed into the water. |
Sodium hypochlorite will not remove taste and smell problems generated by algae and phenols. |
eOxide LQ 85 is very effective to remove taste and smell problems generated by algae and phenols. |
Resistance building is possible by microorganisms against Sodium hypochlorite. Example: Cryptosporidium, Listeria and Legionella. |
eOxide LQ 85 kills all waterborne microorganisms and resistance building is not possible. |
Sodium hypochlorite is dosed in general between 1 and 5 mg/l to disinfect drinking water. A dosage of 3 mg/l of a 10% concentration consumes 30 ml of sodium hypochlorite per 1000 liter of water. |
eOxide LQ 85 is dosed in general between 0,05 and 0,2 mg/l to disinfect drinking water. A dosage of 0,1 mg/l consumes 13,3 ml of product per 1000 liter of water. In most applications a 2/3 reduction of chemical dosage compared to Sodium hypochlorite is realistic. |